Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

Bill 212 — Bike Lane Removal & Liability Immunity

TL;DR

Ford's Bill 212 ordered the removal of 19 kilometres of protected bike lanes in Toronto — overriding the city's elected council — then added a clause barring any cyclist who is injured or killed as a result from suing the province. The Ontario Superior Court found this violates the Charter right to life. The judge explicitly cited the immunity clause as the government's own acknowledgment that people would be seriously hurt. On August 14, 2026, the Court of Appeal unanimously overturned that ruling, clearing the way for removals.

What was promised

Partly kept

Ford's 2025 PC platform promised to remove the Bloor, Yonge and University bike lanes and move them to secondary roads

“Return sanity to bike lanes by removing them from the busiest streets in the province, starting with Bloor Street West, Yonge Street and University Avenue in Toronto, and replacing them on secondary roads. The province will veto and block any future municipal bike lanes that would eliminate a lane of vehicle traffic.”

2025 PC platform, · PC platform, Our Plan to Protect Ontario

What happened · Oct 30, 2026

By Oct. 30, 2026 the province had removed 1.2 km of Bloor Street West lanes; about 18 km on Bloor, Yonge and University remain, with removal planned for the next construction cycle. No replacement bike lanes on secondary roads have been announced.

The removal power and the provincial veto over new bike lanes that take away a car lane were already law before the campaign. Bill 212, the Reducing Gridlock, Saving You Time Act, 2024, received Royal Assent on November 25, 2024. The 2025 budget bill (Bill 24, Royal Assent June 5, 2025) changed the wording from 'removal' to 'reconfiguration' while a court challenge was under way. In July 2025 an Ontario Superior Court judge ruled the removals unconstitutional. On August 14, 2026 the Court of Appeal for Ontario overturned that ruling, which cleared the province to act on about 19 km of protected lanes. In December 2025 the province had restored a car lane on a 600-metre stretch of Bloor West (Resurrection Road to Clissold Road) and kept the bike lane there. On September 1, 2026 it issued a request for proposals for design options to restore car lanes on Bloor, Yonge, University, Queen's Park, Queen's Park Crescent and Avenue Road. It also said it was 'immediately beginning' to restore car lanes on Bloor Street West east of Clissold Road. Cycle Toronto said on September 9 that the RFP closes in December and the remaining work is set to start in spring 2027. No provincial plan to rebuild these lanes on secondary roads has been announced. The transportation minister has only said that streets like King and College would be better alternatives. On October 30, 2026 the province said it had finished removing the bike lanes on Bloor Street West between Clissold Road and Royal York Road (1.2 km) and restored vehicle lanes. Removal began October 13. Transportation Minister Prabmeet Sarkaria said the province is taking bids for contracts to remove 18 more km of lanes on Yonge Street, University Avenue and Bloor Street in the next construction cycle, and that it will release the removal costs once those contracts are done.

Who was hurt

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

Why it matters

The immunity clause is not just a legal technicality — it is a confession. When a government passes legislation and then immediately adds a provision shielding itself from lawsuits arising from that legislation's consequences, it is acknowledging, in legal form, that those consequences include serious injury and death. The Ontario Superior Court said exactly this. In its July 2025 ruling, Justice Peter Osborne explicitly cited the immunity clause as the government's own acknowledgment of the danger it was creating, using it as evidence that the bill violated Section 7 of the Charter — the right to life, liberty, and security of the person.

The court found that removing safe cycling infrastructure from roads where thousands of people ride daily, and then blocking any legal remedy for those who are harmed, constitutes a state-imposed threat to life that requires justification under the Charter. The government could not provide that justification. The ruling was a landmark: it established that Canadians have a constitutional right to safe cycling infrastructure — or at minimum, that the state cannot deliberately remove it while simultaneously immunizing itself from the deaths that result.

The policy's stated rationale was reducing gridlock. Transportation experts and the city's own data showed the bike lanes had a negligible impact on car travel times — and that removing them would not meaningfully reduce congestion. Toronto's own modelling found the lanes had minimal effect on traffic flow. The government did not commission or release any independent traffic analysis before introducing the bill. Its primary effect was not traffic relief but the removal of safe space for cyclists — and the signal to municipalities province-wide that the province could override any local transportation decision at will.

Bill 212 also contained a separate provision accelerating Highway 413 by exempting it from the Environmental Assessment Act, removing public access to environmental study findings, and allowing 24-hour construction. The bike lane removal and the highway fast-track were packaged together in a single bill — infrastructure decisions affecting millions of people, combined without any shared policy logic except that both benefit car traffic over everything else.

Rippling effects

An injunction obtained by Cycle Toronto and Ecojustice in April 2025 has prevented the Ford government from removing the lanes pending the final court decision. As a result, the bike lanes remain in place — not because the government reversed course, but because the courts intervened. The Court of Appeal heard the province's challenge to the injunction in January 2026, and a final ruling on the constitutionality of Bill 212 is still pending as of March 2026. If the government prevails, removals will begin immediately.

The ripple effects extend far beyond Toronto. Bill 212 also granted the province power to prevent any Ontario municipality from installing new bike lanes where a motor vehicle lane would need to be reduced — a sweeping restriction that effectively requires ministerial approval for cycling infrastructure across the entire province. Cities planning protected lanes in Mississauga, Ottawa, Hamilton, and London all face provincial veto power over decisions their own councils vote for. The political signal was unmistakeable: build cycling infrastructure that reduces car lanes at your own risk, and expect the province to override it.

The liability immunity provision, if it survives legal challenge, would set a broader precedent for how Ontario governments can insulate themselves from the consequences of dangerous policy. If a government can remove known safety infrastructure, pre-emptively bar lawsuits from those who are killed or injured as a result, and survive constitutional challenge, that template becomes available for future governments to apply to other dangerous rollbacks. The Ecojustice legal team framing the case as a Charter Section 7 issue is precisely designed to prevent that precedent from being established.

On August 14, 2026, the Ontario Court of Appeal unanimously overturned the ruling that had blocked removal of the roughly 19 kilometres of Bloor, Yonge and University bike lanes. The decision was authored by Justice Grant Huscroft and its reasoning was framed as "Policy is for politics" — that is, the choice to remove the lanes belongs to elected government rather than the courts. The government did not say when or whether removal would begin, and Cycle Toronto said it will "keep pursuing this to the fullest extent of the law."

Linked bills

Sources

  1. CBC — Injured cyclists can't sue province under amendment to bike lane bill
  2. The Trillium — Ford government moves to bar lawsuits over injured, killed cyclists
  3. Ecojustice — Court sides with cyclists: Charter rights violated by Bill 212
  4. Ecojustice — Court challenge launched against Ontario's anti-bike lane law
  5. Ecojustice — Legal file: Challenging Ontario's anti-bike lane law
  6. CBC — Ontario passes Bill 212, bike lanes to be ripped out
  7. CBC — Toronto cyclists defend bike lane challenge at Court of Appeal
  8. CBC — Court challenge launched against Ontario bike lane law
  9. Cycle Toronto — Cycle Toronto v. Ontario (case overview)
  10. Cycle Toronto — What's going on with Bill 212?
  11. Global News — Ford government passes law to remove Ontario bike lanes
  12. The Narwhal — Bill 212 passed: Highway 413 in, bike lanes out
  13. Canadian Public Health Association — CPHA granted intervenor status in Bill 212 challenge
  14. Legislative Assembly of Ontario — Bill 212 full text
  15. Canadian Cycling Magazine — Cyclists return to court as Ontario fights ruling
  16. Ford government wins court appeal in Toronto bike lanes case — Daily Commercial News / Canadian Press
  17. Ford government can rip out Toronto bike lanes, Court of Appeal for Ontario rules — CTV News
  18. Ford government wins court battle over Toronto bike lanes — Global News
  19. Ontario Restoring Vehicle Lanes on Toronto's Busiest Streets — Ontario Newsroom
  20. Ford government says it will move ahead with ripping out bike lanes on stretch of Bloor Street — CP24
  21. Ontario health-care coalition denounces province's plan to remove bike lanes across Toronto — CBC News
  22. Ontario will officially begin removing Toronto bike lanes on Tuesday — CBC News
  23. Province to begin removing Bloor West bike lanes on Tuesday, Chow calls move 'outrageous' — CityNews Toronto
  24. Ford government to remove Etobicoke bike lane on Oct. 13 — The Trillium
  25. Protesters block Ford government's removal of Bloor Street bike lanes in Etobicoke — Toronto Star
  26. Cycling advocates rally, petition Supreme Court to rule on Toronto bike-lane removal — The Globe and Mail
  27. Arrests made at Toronto bike lane removal protest — CTV News (The Canadian Press)
  28. Doug Ford's bike lane battle sparked behind-the-scenes commotion, records reveal — Toronto Star
  29. Ontario Newsroom: Ontario Completes Removal of Bike Lanes on Bloor Street West
  30. CTV News Toronto: Ontario minister says bike lanes 'causing congestion' as he confirms removal of Bloor Street West bike lane
  31. CBC News: Ontario government completes bike lane removal on section of Bloor Street W.
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here