Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

Ontario's Secret Advertising Machine: $452 Million in Partisan Spending

TL;DR

The Ford government has spent $452 million in taxpayer-funded advertising since 2018 — repeatedly refusing to disclose campaign costs until forced by FOI — while the Auditor General found 38% of spending was designed to promote the governing party, and the firm behind the most controversial ad is run by Doug Ford's campaign manager's brother-in-law.

What was promised

Broken

Ford's PCs promised to restore the auditor general's power to block partisan government ads

ParaphraseThe Progressive Conservatives ... promised during the election to restore the auditor general's powers.

Ontario PC Party, 2018 campaign, · 2018 election campaign (date approximate)

What happened · Nov 21, 2021

On Nov. 21, 2021 the premier's office said it was 'maintaining the status quo at this time' and would not restore the auditor general's pre-2015 veto over partisan ads; the veto had still not been restored when the auditor general reported on 2024-25 ad spending in December 2025.

In 2015 the Wynne Liberals narrowed the Government Advertising Act. After that, the auditor general could reject an ad as partisan only if it used a politician's name, voice or image, a party's colour or logo, or attacked another party. Before the change she could also block ads meant to give a 'positive impression' of the government. In opposition the PCs attacked the change, and in 2018 they promised to undo it. In April 2019, Treasury Board President Peter Bethlenfalvy said only 'We're reviewing it.' On Nov. 21, 2021, Ford spokesperson Ivana Yelich said the government was 'maintaining the status quo at this time.' The Canadian Press reported this as the PCs breaking their election promise. Since then the government has run campaigns that the auditor says would have failed the old test. CBC counted at least $38 million on such ads by March 2024, not including the roughly $8 million 'It's Happening Here' campaign. In December 2025, Auditor General Shelley Spence reported record spending of $111.9 million in 2024-25. She flagged nine campaigns worth about $43 million, 38 per cent of the total. In each, the main aim was to foster a 'positive impression' of the government, or the government gave no evidence for some of its claims. The spending came in the run-up to the February 2025 snap election.

Who benefited

  • Doug Ford

    As Premier, Ford's government spent $452 million on taxpayer-funded advertising since 2018 — shattering provincial records — while routinely refusing to disclose campaign costs. The Auditor General found that 38% of spending was designed to foster a positive impression of the governing party. Ford's campaign manager's brother-in-law ran the firm that produced the government's most controversial ads.

  • Todd McCarthy

    As Environment Minister, McCarthy defended the government's $40 million US-facing advertising campaign, stating "We've educated the American public with our ads" — characterizing a campaign the Auditor General flagged as partisan promotion as public information.

  • Google Canada · $1.1M+ (Ontario Place ad campaign)

    Paid more than $1.1 million by Ontario's Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Gaming for the Ontario Place advertising campaign in 2025-26. The ministry spent about $9.38 million on advertising that year, at least $2.19 million of it tied specifically to Ontario Place across digital ads, outdoor advertising and creative services, according to records obtained by The Trillium through a freedom of information request.

  • Pattison Outdoor Advertising · $370,000+ (billboards)

    Paid more than $370,000 by Ontario's Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Gaming for the Ontario Place advertising campaign in 2025-26. Pattison Outdoor Advertising is a billboard company, per The Trillium's reporting on records released under a freedom of information request.

  • Stephen Lecce

    As Minister of Energy and Mines, Lecce heads the ministry whose mines side spent $12.08M on advertising in 2025-26, the vast majority of it on the "Protect Ontario Ring of Fire" campaign, per FOI'd records reported by The Trillium on August 28, 2026. Questions to his office about the spending were referred to Treasury Board President Peter Bethlenfalvy's office.

  • Peter Bethlenfalvy

    Questions about the $12.08M in mines advertising were referred from the Ministry of Energy and Mines to Bethlenfalvy's Treasury Board office, which replied in a single sentence: "As is the case every year, final spending on government advertising will be reflected in the province's public accounts."

  • GroupM Canada · $545,000 in tourism ministry ads, 2025-26

    Named in freedom-of-information records obtained by The Trillium as a recipient of $545,000 in Ontario government advertising money from the Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Gaming in fiscal 2025-26. That ministry spent $9.38 million on advertising over the year, $2.19 million of it tied to Ontario Place. The disclosed documents contained redactions, and the government-wide advertising total for 2025-26 remains unknown — $77M+ across four ministries is only the total disclosed so far.

  • Meta Platforms · Part of $12.08M Ring of Fire ad campaign, 2025-26

    Named in freedom-of-information records obtained by The Trillium as a recipient of Ontario government advertising money under the "Protect Ontario Ring of Fire" campaign, run out of the mines side of the Ministry of Energy and Mines, which spent $12.08 million in fiscal 2025-26. The largest single invoice in the campaign was $3.4 million in March 2026. The disclosed documents contained redactions, and the government-wide advertising total for 2025-26 remains unknown — $77M+ across four ministries is only the total disclosed so far.

  • Cineplex · Part of $12.08M Ring of Fire ad campaign, 2025-26

    Named in freedom-of-information records obtained by The Trillium as a recipient of Ontario government advertising money under the "Protect Ontario Ring of Fire" campaign, run out of the mines side of the Ministry of Energy and Mines, which spent $12.08 million in fiscal 2025-26. The largest single invoice in the campaign was $3.4 million in March 2026. The disclosed documents contained redactions, and the government-wide advertising total for 2025-26 remains unknown — $77M+ across four ministries is only the total disclosed so far.

  • Fox News · $17.6M earmarked

    Global News, citing FOI documents, reports the province earmarked $17.6 million to buy advertising space on four Fox News prime-time shows within its U.S. advertising campaign; the Auditor General's report also lists Fox among the networks carrying the $33 million prime-time buy.

    Source: Ford government commercials on Fox News, U.S. media cost tens of millions, docs show — Global News, Ontario spends record $112-million on advertising, A-G report says — The Globe and Mail

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

The web

11 people
Show 5 more

Why it matters

Ontario's Government Advertising Act was designed with a clear principle: public money cannot be used for the governing party's political benefit. Under Dalton McGuinty's original 2004 version of the law, the Auditor General had authority to block any campaign whose "primary purpose" was to foster a positive impression of the governing party. That oversight was gutted in 2015 when the Wynne Liberals narrowed the definition to only prohibit ads featuring politicians by name, face, or party logo. The Ford PCs campaigned in 2018 on a promise to restore the original rules. Once in power, they never did — and proceeded to exploit the loophole with unprecedented aggression.

The pattern of secrecy began in 2019. When the Ford government launched anti-carbon tax radio and TV ads called "One Little Nickel," Treasury Board President Peter Bethlenfalvy refused to reveal the cost, saying only: "We've got a budget for letting the people of Ontario know exactly what is going on." The Globe and Mail reported the refusal. Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk later confirmed the campaign cost $4 million and said she would have rejected it as partisan — but could not under the weakened law. The same pattern repeated with "Ontario Is Getting Stronger" in 2022 ($13.5 million), "It's Happening Here" in 2023-24 (eventually $40 million via two separate FOI requests), and "Protect Ontario" in 2025 — each time requiring journalists to file Freedom of Information requests to learn what public money was being spent.

In December 2025, Auditor General Shelley Spence reported that Ontario spent a record $111.9 million on advertising in 2024-25 — the highest in provincial history. She found that 38% of campaigns were "designed to foster a positive impression of the Progressive Conservatives, rather than give Ontarians information about government programs or services." The $43 million "It's Happening Here" campaign alone aired during the Super Bowl, the Oscars, the Emmy Awards, and NHL prime time. Spence was direct: "Some of the ads are quite promotional for the governing party. They aren't really providing really good, solid information to the citizens of Ontario."

The advertising machine also has a documented insider pipeline. The controversial Reagan anti-tariff commercial — which ultimately angered Donald Trump enough to halt trade talks — was produced by Creative Currency, an ad firm run by Dennis Matthews. Matthews' wife and PC campaign manager Kory Teneycke's wife are sisters. Creative Currency received $4.8 million from the Ontario PC party since 2022 and approximately $2.2 million in taxpayer-funded government contracts. VP Lauren McDonald previously served as Director of Marketing in the Premier's own office. Global News confirmed the ties between the firm and Ford's political network.

Beyond partisan content, the government has actively prevented accountability about spending before the public can act on the information. The government consistently stated that ad costs "will be released through public accounts" — a document published months after the spending occurs. The January 2025 snap election was called while a $40 million domestic ad blitz was still running, and only when the government entered caretaker mode were 15 of its own flagged campaigns paused. The combination of a weakened advertising law, routine refusals to disclose spending, and a contractor network connected to the Premier's political operation raises questions that Ontario's accountability institutions have consistently flagged but cannot currently enforce.

Rippling effects

The weakening of the Government Advertising Act in 2015 — done by the Liberals, exploited by the PCs — has created a structural accountability gap that cannot be fixed by the Auditor General alone. AG Spence's annual reports flag partisan spending but have no enforcement power: the government is informed, acknowledges the findings, and continues. The Public Accounts Committee recommended restoring the AG's pre-2015 authority and extending oversight to digital advertising — but the Ford government's response was to maintain "the status quo." Ontario's Auditor General cannot veto a single ad regardless of how partisan it is.

Digital advertising has become a parallel, unregulated spending channel. The government spent $12.8 million on digital ads excluded from the Auditor General's review in 2023-24 — a more than 250% increase from the year before. Ads placed on Meta platforms, X (formerly Twitter), and other digital channels fall entirely outside the Government Advertising Act review framework. The Auditor General has called for this gap to be closed. The government has not acted. This means a growing fraction of public spending on political self-promotion is invisible even to Ontario's watchdog.

The Creative Currency/Teneycke network illustrates how the advertising apparatus has been integrated into the Ford government's political infrastructure. The same organizational circle — campaign manager, his brother-in-law's ad firm, a VP who previously ran marketing out of the Premier's office — produces both partisan PC election materials and taxpayer-funded government advertising. Whether this constitutes a breach of any specific rule is a legal question that has not been formally examined. But it represents exactly the blurring of government and party that the original 2004 advertising law was designed to prevent.

The FOI barrier compounds the problem. Costs of major campaigns are routinely withheld until journalists file formal access-to-information requests — a process that takes 30 or more days and requires knowing what to ask for. The "It's Happening Here" campaign required two separate FOI requests to piece together the full $40 million cost. As recently as 2025, the government launched a new "Protect Ontario" commercial and again refused to reveal its cost, leaving the public no way to know how much of their money was being spent.

Until the law changes, Ontario taxpayers have no legal protection against their money being used to re-elect the government that spends it. NDP Leader Marit Stiles introduced Bill 54 to restore partisan advertising restrictions — it remains stalled at first reading. Finance Minister Peter Bethlenfalvy has offered the definitive government position: "I am never going to apologize for promoting Ontario."

Freedom-of-information records obtained by The Trillium show the Ministry of Finance spent $21,397,155.73 on advertising in 2025-26, with roughly $19.5 million of that going to the production and distribution of "Protect Ontario" ads. About $3.6 million of the ministry's spending went to Publicis Canada Inc. for the "creative" work on those ads.

Publicis is one of Supply Ontario's vendors of record. In November 2025, Alexandra Sutton, deputy minister of intergovernmental affairs and Cabinet Office communications, told a parliamentary committee that the government chose Publicis through "a competitive procurement." The firm's provincial work is not confined to Finance: eight ministries paid Publicis about $9 million combined in 2024-25. GroupM is described in The Trillium's reporting as the Ford government's preferred media-buying agency. On the distribution side, Google Canada pulled in roughly $4 million to carry the Finance ads, with LinkedIn and Meta playing smaller roles.

The auditor general found that the "Affordability" campaign seemed "designed to improve Ontarians' impression of the current state of Ontario, the subtext of which promotes the governing party." Asked about the figures, Sarah Chapin, communications director for the minister of finance, gave a one-sentence response: "The final expenditure on ad spending will be made available, as is the case every year, through public accounts."

Linked bills

Sources

  1. Ontario spends record $112M on advertising, AG report says — Globe and Mail
  2. Ontario launches taxpayer-funded anti-carbon-tax ads, won't reveal cost — Globe and Mail
  3. Government launches new 'Protect Ontario' commercial, won't reveal cost — Global News
  4. Ontario launches new US anti-tariff campaign — Global News
  5. Ontario Reagan commercial produced by firm with ties to Doug Ford's PC party — Global News
  6. Ontario pauses 15 government advertising campaigns deemed to be partisan — Global News
  7. Ontario Liberals ask Auditor General to review government ads running during election — Global News
  8. Ontario spent record sum on advertisements 'to promote' governing party: AG — Global News
  9. Ford government commercials on Fox News, US media cost tens of millions — Global News
  10. Ontario government spending $112M on ads, more than ever before: Auditor — CP24
  11. Ontario government spending $112M on advertising, more than ever before: Auditor — CHCH News
  12. Ontario government spending $112M on advertising, more than ever before — QP Briefing
  13. Bill 54, End the Public Funding of Partisan Government Advertising Act, 2025 — Legislative Assembly of Ontario
  14. Public Accounts Committee: Review of Government Advertising (2023 AG Report) — Legislative Assembly of Ontario
  15. Hansard, May 27 2025 — Legislative Assembly of Ontario
  16. Ontario Auditor General Tables 2025 Annual Report — Newswire
  17. Taxpayers Federation calls on Ford to cut advertising spending — Canadian Taxpayers Federation
  18. Ford government set aside $2M for Ontario Place advertisements to counter 'negative sentiment' — Global News
  19. About — Creative Currency
  20. Ford campaign manager partnered with U.S. firm that received Ontario government contract — Global News
  21. Office of the Auditor General of Ontario 2021 Annual Report — Office of the Auditor General
  22. Ford government spent over $2M on Ontario Place ads last year: records — The Trillium
  23. Finance ministry spent $21.4M on 'Protect Ontario' and affordability-focused ads in 2025-26 — The Trillium
  24. Ford government spent over $2M on Ontario Place ads last year: records — The Trillium (via Sudbury.com)
  25. Ford government spent over $12M advertising Ring of Fire plans last year: records — The Trillium (via Sudbury.com)
  26. Ontario Health Ministry spent $13.3M on advertising last year — The Trillium
  27. Ford government spent all-time high on ads in 2025-26: records — The Trillium
  28. Ford government spent all-time high on ads in 2025-26: records — BayToday (The Trillium)
  29. WASTE: Ford government spent record-high $117 million on advertising — Canadian Taxpayers Federation
  30. CBC News: 'Largely ineffective': Ontarians not impressed with Ford's work on public safety, according to poll
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here