Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

Starlink Secret Payout — Ford Cancels Deal, Refuses to Disclose Cost to Taxpayers

TL;DR

Doug Ford signed a $100-million Starlink broadband deal to appeal to Trump's inner circle, then abruptly cancelled it in response to Trump's tariffs. He then negotiated a confidential settlement to pay Elon Musk an undisclosed sum — and refuses to tell Ontario taxpayers how much public money they're handing over to the world's richest person, citing a confidentiality clause that he could have negotiated away.

What was promised

Broken

Doug Ford said Ontario 'won't back down' on its U.S. electricity surcharge until the tariff threat was gone

“Until the threat of tariffs is gone for good, Ontario won't back down. We'll stand strong, use every tool in our toolkit and do whatever it takes to protect Ontario.”

Doug Ford, · Ontario Newsroom release on electricity surcharge

What happened · Mar 11, 2025

Ford suspended the surcharge the next day while U.S. tariffs on Canadian goods stayed in place, and it has not been reimposed.

The 25 per cent surcharge on electricity exports to Michigan, Minnesota and New York took effect March 10, 2025. On March 11, after a call in which U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick invited him to talks in Washington, Ford agreed to suspend it. He called the invitation an "olive branch" and said "cooler heads" needed to prevail. The White House dropped its threat to double steel and aluminum tariffs, but the 25 per cent tariff on Canadian steel and aluminum took effect. The province said the one-day surcharge raised $260,000. As of late August 2026 the surcharge had not been reimposed. Ford said then that it should be reintroduced if the trade war escalated further.

Partly kept

Ford promised to ban American companies from Ontario government contracts until U.S. tariffs are removed

“Starting today and until US tariffs are removed, Ontario is banning American companies from provincial contracts.”

Doug Ford, · Post on X

What happened · Apr 13, 2026

A Procurement Restriction Policy has been in force since March 4, 2025, but it is narrower than the promised ban on "American companies". U.S.-headquartered firms with 250 or more full-time employees in Canada, and existing vendor-of-record arrangements, are exempt.

Ford's Procurement Restriction Policy, in force since March 4, 2025, restricts U.S. businesses from new Ontario public-sector procurements. As BetaKit reported in April 2025, the policy only counts a company as a "US business" if it is headquartered in the U.S. and has fewer than 250 full-time employees in Canada. It does not apply to existing vendor-of-record arrangements, and U.S. firms can still be used where they are the only viable source. On April 13, 2026, the policy was folded into the binding Buy Ontario Procurement Directive. The directive keeps the restriction and adds a new exception for U.S. service providers that commit to having at least 90 per cent of their staff in Canada.

Broken

Ford promised high-speed internet access in every region of Ontario by the end of 2025

“We’re on track to bring high-speed internet access…To every region in Ontario by the end of 2025.”

Doug Ford, · Speech, Rural Ontario Municipal Association conference

What happened · Oct 31, 2025

The end-of-2025 deadline passed without universal access; the government itself moved the target to 2028.

In late October 2025 Global News reported, and the government confirmed, that Ontario would miss its end-of-2025 target for connecting every community to high-speed internet. The new deadline is mid-2028. Officials blamed construction delays in remote areas and the March 2025 cancellation of the $100-million Starlink satellite contract, which left no ready replacement for about 15,000 remote northern homes. Ford said in November 2025 that he did not regret cancelling the Starlink deal. The province's own progress page said that as of April 2026, 96% of Ontario had access, and it now describes the goal as connecting every community 'by the end of 2028'.

Who benefited

Who benefited

  • SpaceX (Starlink) · $100M contract (payout amount undisclosed)

    Ontario signed a $100 million contract (the ONSAT program) with SpaceX/Starlink to provide satellite internet to 15,000 rural and northern households. Premier Ford cancelled the contract in March 2025 and the province negotiated a confidential settlement/kill-fee payout to SpaceX that remains undisclosed to the public.

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

The web

5 people

Why it matters

The Starlink deal cancellation and secret payout reveal the Ford government's approach to public money: it is theirs to spend, negotiate away, or conceal as they see fit. The confidentiality clause may be legally binding, but Ford's government agreed to it. They chose secrecy over transparency. They chose to shield themselves from accountability over serving the public's right to know.

The original deal itself was problematic — a $100-million broadband contract justified on grounds of currying favour with Trump rather than serving Ontario's actual broadband needs. Rural broadband access is a real policy challenge, and it deserves to be funded based on engineering assessments of where service gaps exist and cost-benefit analyses of different solutions. Instead, Ford used a $100-million public contract as a political tool, offered it to signal deference to a foreign leader, then cancelled it when that political calculation changed. The settlement that followed — an undisclosed cost to make the problem disappear — represents the logical endpoint of that approach: when the political cost of transparency exceeds the government's tolerance, simply hide it.

The pattern is consistent with the broader FOI scandal. When the Ford government faces accountability mechanisms — courts, watchdogs, legislatures with subpoena power, or confidentiality clauses in contracts — its instinct is to eliminate, evade, or exploit them. The Starlink agreement shows this pattern in action: a contract and settlement negotiated without competitive bidding, a payout to one of the world's richest people funded by taxpayers, and the actual cost concealed from the public through a confidentiality clause the government could have challenged or refused.

Rippling effects

The immediate rippling effect is on Ontario's rural broadband strategy. The $100-million Starlink deal is gone. No alternative broadband expansion program has been announced. Rural Ontario's broadband gap — which was purportedly the justification for the Starlink deal — remains unfilled. Whatever amount the province ultimately paid to cancel the deal is money that cannot be spent on actual broadband infrastructure.

The precedent set by the confidentiality clause is also troubling. If the Ford government can negotiate public contracts with confidentiality clauses that prevent disclosure of the settlement amount, then future deals — for infrastructure, services, land, or anything else — could similarly be shielded from public scrutiny. The principle that public money should be subject to public accounting is eroded when the government agrees to spend that money in secret.

The incident also illustrates the risks of using government contracts as tools for foreign policy or personal favour-currying. The Starlink deal was never a serious broadband policy; it was a signal to Trump. When Trump's tariff threats made the signal counterproductive, the deal was cancelled. That approach to public money — as a tool for political messaging rather than public benefit — costs Ontario taxpayers in the form of settlement payments for deals that should never have been made in the first place.

Finally, the refusal to disclose the settlement amount adds to the broader erosion of government transparency that the FOI scandal represents. The government claims confidentiality clauses prevent disclosure. What it does not say is that those clauses were drafted by the government's negotiators, and those negotiators could have drafted differently. The choice to conceal the cost was a choice.

Sources

  1. Ford government says 'people voted' to cancel Starlink deal, won't reveal cost — Global News
  2. CBC News — Confidential settlement for scuttled Starlink deal means Ontarians kept in dark on payout
  3. CP24 — Ontario's payout to Elon Musk over cancelled Starlink contract to remain secret
  4. Global News — Ontario's payout to Elon Musk over cancelled Starlink contract to remain secret
  5. iPhone in Canada — Ontario Hides Secret Payout to Elon Musk's SpaceX Over Failed Starlink Deal
  6. Mobile Syrup — Ontario, Starlink won't disclose payout over cancelled contract
  7. The Trillium — Ontario's payout to Elon Musk over cancelled Starlink contract to remain secret
  8. CBC News — Ford government cancels $100-million Starlink broadband deal
  9. Ontario ministers defend secret payout to Elon Musk's SpaceX over nixed Starlink deal — The Canadian Press (via CP24)
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here