Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

The Greenbelt Scandal

$8.3B+Cost to Ontario

27 sources ↓

TL;DR

Premier Doug Ford secretly handed 15 parcels of protected Greenbelt farmland to well-connected developers through a three-week backroom process — a windfall worth $8.3 billion to those developers — and only reversed it after the Auditor General publicly exposed the scheme.

What was promised

Broken

Calandra said the province would help cover municipalities' costs from his official-plan reversals; Guelph and Wellington County say they were never paid

“In recognition of the costs incurred by municipalities arising out of this decision, the province will work with impacted municipalities to assist with related planning and staffing costs.”

Paul Calandra, · Minister's statement, Ontario Newsroom

What happened · Aug 24, 2026

A September 2024 ministry briefing note said no decision had been made on reimbursement and the ministry had not asked municipalities for their costs; Guelph and Wellington County, both covered by the statement, told CBC in August 2026 they had not been reimbursed.

Calandra's October 23, 2023 statement reversed provincial changes to the official plans of 12 municipalities, including Guelph and Wellington County, and pledged help with the resulting planning and staffing costs. A briefing note obtained by CBC News through freedom of information says that, on Calandra's direction about five months later, 'the ministry has not done any proactive outreach to municipalities to solicit cost submissions' and that 'no decision has been made on reimbursement.' In August 2026 Guelph and Wellington County confirmed to CBC they had not been reimbursed; Guelph put its cost at nearly $64,000. Pickering, Durham Region and Grimsby, whose separate claims relate to the Greenbelt removals, also say they have not been paid. The province did not respond to CBC's request for comment.

Who was hurt

Kept

Calandra said developers would get no compensation for the Greenbelt reversal

“At this point nothing had changed. The lands had been temporarily moved out of the Greenbelt, but no zoning had been changed, the circumstances for them had not changed, so that's why I'm not going to be offering any compensation.”

Paul Calandra, · Remarks to reporters (The Canadian Press)

What happened · Aug 28, 2026

The 2023 act that restored the lands added immunity provisions that wiped out related claims, the Court of Appeal upheld them on August 28, 2026, and no compensation payment has been reported.

The Greenbelt Statute Law Amendment Act, 2023 (Royal Assent December 6, 2023) 'strengthens immunity provisions', according to the ministry's decision notice. It also ended the province's 2022 settlement with Minotar Holdings. The Superior Court dismissed Minotar's constitutional challenge in March 2025. On August 28, 2026, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal 2-1. Minotar filed a separate claim in November 2025 seeking $300 million for breach of contract, and that claim has not been decided.

Broken

Calandra tabled a motion to approve Steve Clark's reprimand, then never called it for a vote

“That the Legislative Assembly accept the report of the Integrity Commissioner dated August 30, 2023 and approve the recommendation contained therein.”

Paul Calandra, · Government notice of motion (Motion 17), Orders and Notices

What happened · Oct 26, 2023

The government never called its own motion for debate or a vote, and the government House leader told the House on October 26, 2023 he had "no intention of moving forward beyond that."

On August 30, 2023, Integrity Commissioner J. David Wake found that Steve Clark contravened sections 2 and 3(2) of the Members' Integrity Act, 1994 and recommended that the Assembly reprimand him. On September 25, 2023, Government House Leader Paul Calandra filed a motion to approve that recommendation and the same day sought unanimous consent to put it to a vote without debate or amendment, which was refused. On October 26, 2023, asked when the motion would be debated, Calandra said that because Clark had accepted responsibility and resigned, he had "no intention of moving forward beyond that." The motion was still listed on the Orders and Notices Paper, never debated or voted on, as of December 5, 2024.

Kept

Ford promised to reverse the Greenbelt removals and make no further Greenbelt changes

“As a first step to earn back your trust, I'll be reversing the changes we made and won't make any changes to the Greenbelt in the future.”

Doug Ford, · News conference, PC caucus retreat, Niagara Falls

What happened · Dec 6, 2023

The Greenbelt Statute Law Amendment Act, 2023 put all 15 removed sites back in the Greenbelt and made future boundary changes require an act of the legislature, and e-Laws shows no amendment to the Greenbelt Act since.

Calandra introduced Bill 136 on October 16, 2023, and it received Royal Assent on December 6, 2023. The ministry's decision notice says the act 'restore[s] the 15 areas of land that were redesignated or removed from the Greenbelt in December 2022' and 'ensures that any future changes to the Greenbelt boundary can only be made through legislation.' The Greenbelt Act, 2005 on e-Laws lists no amendment after the 2023 act (checked October 2026).

Broken

Ford's office promised a committee review of lobbying and ethics laws; the Auditor General found little or no progress

“Additionally, we accept your recommendation regarding a comprehensive overall review of the Lobbyists Registration Act, 1998 (LRA), Members' Integrity Act, 1994, (MIA) and Public Service of Ontario Act, 2006 (PSOA). ... we will initiate a review of all three acts in advance of the prescribed legislative timelines in a comprehensive manner at an independent legislative committee to ensure and strengthen regulatory oversight.”

Premier's Office, response to the Auditor General, · Response to Auditor General's Greenbelt special report

What happened · Dec 10, 2025

The Auditor General reported in December 2025 that the review had made "little or no progress" with no planned course of action or target date, and the Integrity Commissioner called the reviews "long overdue" in July 2026.

The Premier's Office accepted the Auditor General's Recommendation 15 in the August 9, 2023 Greenbelt report and committed to a review of all three ethics and lobbying statutes at an independent legislative committee. On September 6, 2023, the Attorney General's office said the government would review lobbying legislation "in the coming weeks" and that the Premier had recommended increased penalties "up to and including jail time." In her follow-up report released December 10, 2025, the Auditor General rated Recommendation 15 "Little or no progress," reporting that as of July 2025 the government "continues to consider" a review and had no planned course of action or target date. In her 2025-2026 annual report (July 2026), Integrity Commissioner Cathryn Motherwell again called for reviews of the three acts, saying they "are long overdue"; the Lobbyists Registration Act's offence penalties remain fines of up to $25,000 for a first offence and $100,000 for subsequent offences, with no jail term.

Not yet due

Ford: build 1.5 million homes by 2031

“Our plan to get shovels in the ground to build 1.5 million new homes will help keep costs down for families by building the supply that meets homeownership demand.”

Doug Ford, · 2022 campaign stop, London

What happened · Oct 29, 2026

The deadline is 2031, but the province missed its own annual targets in 2024 and 2025, and internal ministry notes from fall 2024 say '1.5 million homes not reach target'.

The province set interim annual targets of 110,000 (2023), 125,000 (2024), 150,000 (2025) and 175,000 a year from 2026. It met 2023 only after counting long-term care beds, reached 94,908 of 125,000 in 2024 by its own tracker, and, per a briefing note obtained by Global News, 86,760 of 150,000 (58%) in 2025, even after counting basement suites, long-term care beds, retirement suites and student beds. Handwritten housing ministry notes from October–December 2024, obtained by Global News in June 2026, read '1.5 million homes not reach target'. Finance Minister Peter Bethlenfalvy has called the goal a 'soft target'. The Oct. 29, 2026 fall economic statement projects housing starts of 64,700 in 2026, down from 65,400 in 2025, flat in 2027, then 71,700 in 2028 and 75,400 in 2029 (The Canadian Press).

Broken, then reversed

Clark said Ontario would not entertain any proposal to move or open Greenbelt lands

“I want to be clear. We will not in any way entertain any proposals that will move lands in the Greenbelt, or open the Greenbelt lands to any kind of development.”

Steve Clark, · News conference on Greenbelt expansion consultation

What happened · Dec 6, 2023

Clark's ministry proposed removing about 7,400 acres from the Greenbelt in November 2022 and the removals took effect in December 2022; the government then put all 15 sites back by law on December 6, 2023.

On November 4, 2022, Clark announced a consultation on removing about 7,400 acres in 15 areas from the Greenbelt to build at least 50,000 homes. The removals took effect on December 14, 2022. After the Auditor General's and Integrity Commissioner's reports, the government restored all 15 sites through the Greenbelt Statute Law Amendment Act, 2023, which received Royal Assent on December 6, 2023.

Who benefited

Who was hurt

Broken, then reversed

Ford: 'The people have spoken — we won't touch the Greenbelt'

“I govern through the people, I don't govern through government. The people have spoken − we won't touch the Greenbelt.”

Doug Ford, · 2018 campaign, written statement to reporters

What happened · Sep 21, 2023

The government removed about 7,400 acres from the Greenbelt in November 2022, then, after watchdog reports and two ministers' resignations, Ford apologized, said 'I broke that promise', and reversed the removals.

In November 2022 the government removed 2,995 hectares across 15 sites from the Greenbelt for housing, while adding about 3,804 hectares elsewhere. In August 2023 the Auditor General found the site selection favoured certain developers whose land stood to rise $8.3 billion in value, and the Integrity Commissioner found Housing Minister Steve Clark breached the Members' Integrity Act. On September 21, 2023 Ford said, 'I made a promise to you that I wouldn't touch the Greenbelt. I broke that promise,' and announced the removals would be reversed. Housing Minister Paul Calandra then tabled the Greenbelt Statute Law Amendment Act, 2023 (Bill 136, 43rd Parliament), which restored the boundaries, required future boundary changes to go through the legislature, and was enacted in December 2023.

Who benefited

Who was hurt

Who benefited

Who was hurt

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

The web

19 people
Show 13 more

Why it matters

The Ontario Greenbelt is a 2-million-acre ring of protected farmland, wetlands, and forests encircling the Greater Toronto Area — the largest protected greenbelt in the world and a critical defence against urban sprawl. The Ford government's 2022 decision to open 15 parcels for development was not random: it was designed in a three-week process that excluded the government's own land-use planning experts and relied almost entirely on packages submitted by well-connected private developers.

The Auditor General found that 95% of the parcels were identified by Ryan Amato, chief of staff to Housing Minister Steve Clark — not by planners or civil servants — and that 92% of the total acreage came from packages handed to Amato by just two developers at a private industry event in September 2022. The process was, the AG wrote, not transparent, fair, objective, or fully informed.

The developers who owned 14 of the 15 parcels stood to gain $8.3 billion in increased property value — a public subsidy of staggering size with no benefit to Ontario taxpayers. Among the key beneficiaries: Silvio De Gasperis (TACC Developments), Michael Rice (Rice Group, who bought his parcels just weeks before the announcement), and Shakir Rehmatullah (Flato Developments), a self-described friend of the Premier.

Ford himself claimed he was unaware of Amato's central role — a claim widely disputed. The Integrity Commissioner's investigation found Housing Minister Clark had violated ethics rules by delegating decision-making to Amato without oversight. The RCMP launched a criminal investigation in October 2023 into whether the changes corruptly favoured certain developers — an investigation still ongoing as of early 2026.

Of the land removed: 83% was classified as prime agricultural land — the highest-quality farmland in Ontario — and the changes eliminated environmental protections for approximately 404 hectares of woodlands and wetlands. Ontario already loses 319 acres of farmland per day; this decision would have accelerated that.

Government activity on this file

via PoliMon · updated hourly
  • committees · Greenbelt, Auditor General, value-for-moneynew
    Standing Committee on Public Accounts 2026-11-02
    Nov 3, 2026

    …een this before with the Skills Development Fund and we have seen this with the greenbelt: hundreds of millions of public dollars at stake; all warranted Auditor General…

Rippling effects

The immediate political fallout was severe. Housing Minister Steve Clark resigned in September 2023 after the Integrity Commissioner found he had violated ethics rules. Days later, Kaleed Rasheed, Minister of Public and Business Service Delivery, also resigned over his own relationship with a Greenbelt developer. Ryan Amato, the staffer who orchestrated the land selection, resigned in August 2023 — but not before receiving a full year's salary as severance courtesy of Ontario taxpayers.

Ford reversed the Greenbelt changes on September 21, 2023, issuing a public apology — a rare moment of contrition from a premier who had spent months defending the policy. The legislature subsequently passed Bill 136, the Greenbelt Statute Law Amendment Act, 2023, restoring the Greenbelt's original boundaries and requiring future changes to receive legislative approval. But legal challenges immediately followed: developer Minotar Holdings launched a constitutional challenge in December 2023, arguing the reversal was politically motivated and voided their legitimate land investments.

A $2.2-million civil lawsuit filed in early 2025 alleges that Amato and fellow staffer Shiv Raj used "backchannel contacts" to promise fast-tracked rezoning approvals to a developer in exchange for $1.5 million — then failed to deliver. The lawsuit lifts the lid on what critics say was a broader culture of pay-to-play access in Ford's housing file.

The scandal has fundamentally damaged public trust in Ontario's land-use planning system, demonstrated that protected spaces are only as safe as the political will to defend them, and shown that a small circle of connected developers could reshape provincial policy through a few informal meetings. The RCMP investigation — still active with no charges as of 2026 — hangs over the Ford government as it enters its third term.

Nearly three years after the land swap was reversed, the bill for it has not been settled. Pickering, Guelph and the Region of Durham told CP24 on August 24, 2026 that Ontario still hasn't reimbursed them for the costs they incurred from the Greenbelt land swap and its reversal. Pickering puts its own shortfall at roughly $360,000 in direct and indirect costs. The reimbursement pledge was made by then-Housing Minister Paul Calandra.

The criminal side of the file is also unresolved. The RCMP's Sensitive and International Investigations Unit says its investigation remains ongoing and that it "cannot provide information at this time." No charges have been laid. Green Party leader Mike Schreiner is among the critics quoted in CP24's reporting.

Linked bills

Sources

  1. Special Report on Changes to the Greenbelt — Auditor General of Ontario (August 2023)
  2. Ontario government's Greenbelt land swap influenced by well-connected developers, AG finds — CBC News
  3. Doug Ford and Ontario's Greenbelt: a timeline — The Narwhal
  4. RCMP investigating Ontario government's plan to open Greenbelt land for development — CBC News
  5. A timeline of key events in Ontario's Greenbelt controversy — CBC News
  6. How Doug Ford's Greenbelt land swap backfired — The Narwhal
  7. Who is Ryan Amato, the political staffer at the centre of Ontario's Greenbelt scandal? — The Trillium
  8. Lawsuit alleges former Ford staffers promised to use 'backchannel contacts' to get land rezoned — CBC News
  9. A year after Ontario's Greenbelt scandal, what's changed? — The Narwhal
  10. RCMP's 'thorough' Greenbelt investigation reaches 2-year mark — Global News
  11. Former Ford staffer challenges watchdog order for Greenbelt interview under oath — Global News
  12. Ford government's FOI changes block release of Greenbelt investment-opportunity meeting records — Burlington Today
  13. Inside the Greenbelt scandal's lost Leafs game — The Trillium
  14. Inside the Greenbelt scandal's lost Leafs game — Sudbury.com (The Trillium)
  15. Several municipalities say Ontario still hasn't paid them for Greenbelt-related expenses — CP24
  16. Ontario municipalities still waiting for promised Greenbelt reimbursement — CBC News
  17. Ontario Court of Appeal rejects developer's constitutional challenge over Greenbelt reversal — CBC News
  18. Three years later, RCMP says investigation into Doug Ford's Greenbelt scandal is still 'ongoing' — Toronto Star
  19. 'No one is above law': RCMP probe into Ford's Greenbelt scandal reaches 3-year mark — The Pointer
  20. 'It's unfair': Silence and uncertainty define RCMP's Greenbelt investigation at 3-year mark — The Trillium
  21. David Piccini's assistant sent developer's request to housing minister's office before land was removed from Greenbelt — The Trillium
  22. David Piccini's assistant sent developer's request to housing minister's office before land was removed from Greenbelt — TimminsToday (The Trillium)
  23. Former Ontario mayor dubbed 'Mr. X' banned from lobbying province for 2 years — CBC News
  24. Former Ford aide broke lobbying rules for Greenbelt: integrity commissioner — CBC News
  25. Doug Ford's former assistant broke law lobbying for Greenbelt removals: integrity commissioner — The Trillium
  26. The Trillium: Messages contradict what ex-staffer told Greenbelt scandal inquiry
  27. Northumberland News (Metroland): Piccini faces review request over past dealing with lobbyist
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here