Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

FIPPA Overhaul — Ford Makes All Premier and Cabinet Records Permanently Secret

TL;DR

The Ford government buried amendments inside the 2026 Budget Bill that would permanently exempt the Premier, all cabinet ministers, and their staff from freedom-of-information requests — retroactive to 1988 — nullifying every pending FOI request and active court case, including those seeking Doug Ford's personal cellphone records and Greenbelt-related emails. Ontario's own privacy watchdog publicly called three of Ford's stated justifications factually incorrect.

Who benefited

  • Ryan Amato

    As former chief of staff, Amato's personal-account emails about the Greenbelt land removals are subject to an IPC order requiring disclosure. The retroactive FIPPA amendments would nullify that order, permanently shielding his records from public scrutiny.

  • Patrick Sackville

    As former Chief of Staff, Sackville's personal-account emails about the Greenbelt land removals are among the records subject to IPC proceedings. He told the Integrity Commissioner he did not use personal email for government business — a claim contradicted by documentary evidence uncovered by Global News. The retroactive FIPPA amendments would permanently shield those communications from public scrutiny.

Who was hurt

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

The web

12 people
Show 6 more
2 linked billsSee the full web →

Why it matters

The FIPPA amendments were not introduced as standalone legislation — they were buried inside the 2026 Budget Bill, an omnibus measure that limited the scrutiny any single committee or affected group could mount before hearings closed. Global News reported that the changes would permanently exempt the Premier, all cabinet ministers, parliamentary assistants, and their staff from freedom-of-information requests, retroactive to 1988 — the year the original act was passed. Burying a sweeping accountability rollback inside a budget bill is not incidental; it is a deliberate procedural choice designed to minimize public and opposition scrutiny of legislation that directly benefits the people passing it.

The retroactivity is the most legally aggressive element. The amendments would not just shield future records — they would nullify every active and pending FOI request reaching back to 1988. That includes a December 2025 court ruling upholding an IPC order requiring disclosure of Doug Ford's personal cellphone call logs used for government business, and an IPC order requiring former chief of staff Ryan Amato to hand over Greenbelt-related emails sent from his personal accounts. These are not abstract future proceedings — these are specific, active accountability mechanisms that the amendments are designed to terminate. National Observer documented how the amendments would affect the ongoing Greenbelt scandal proceedings and the broader pattern of Freedom of Information obstruction documented across this government.

Information and Privacy Commissioner Patricia Kosseim published a formal rebuttal fact-checking three specific Ford government justifications. First, the government claimed 75,000 FOI requests are filed in Ontario annually — the actual figure is approximately 27,000. Second, the government claimed only media outlets file FOI requests — the IPC's data shows 96% of requests come from businesses and individuals. Third, the government claimed the changes would align Ontario with other provinces — the IPC said the proposal would make Ontario one of the most secretive governments in the country. Beyond the three false statistics, the IPC also identified a cybersecurity paradox at the heart of Ford's stated rationale: the government argued that keeping records on personal devices improves cybersecurity, but the IPC noted that personal devices are less secure than government systems, not more. The IPC's formal statement is a direct public contradiction of the government's own stated reasoning, from the office constitutionally responsible for enforcing the act.

The code-word context matters here. The Ford government previously used "G*" as an internal code word for "Greenbelt" in emails specifically to prevent those records from appearing in FOI keyword searches — a deliberate obstruction tactic documented during the Greenbelt scandal investigation. Under the FIPPA amendments, that pattern of obstruction would receive permanent legislative protection. Beyond the Greenbelt, active FOI battles over Skills Development Fund records — covering hundreds of millions in government grants to politically connected recipients — would be retroactively shielded. National Observer reported on how the IPC's formal rebuttal connected the amendment's real-world impact to the specific accountability proceedings the government was seeking to terminate.

Rippling effects

Every other active scandal's pending FOI requests would be permanently shielded by the retroactive exemption. The Greenbelt scandal proceedings — including the IPC order requiring Ryan Amato to produce personal-account emails — would be nullified. Active FOI battles over Skills Development Fund grants to connected recipients would be terminated. Pending requests related to Minister's Zoning Orders issued to politically connected developers would be retroactively immune. The 1988 retroactivity date is not a technical formality — it means every record created by every Premier and every cabinet minister over nearly four decades becomes permanently unreachable by the public, journalists, or the courts.

Ontario would become more secretive than any other province in Canada. The IPC stated plainly that the proposal would place Ontario in a minority of the most secretive jurisdictions globally — not just among Canadian provinces. The ongoing court cases brought by the Globe and Mail and CBC seeking Ford's personal cellphone call logs, which a December 2025 court ruling already upheld as disclosable, would be terminated with no remedy available to the plaintiffs. The Globe and Mail reported that advocates and legal experts described the amendments as the most significant single rollback of public access rights in Ontario's history. Journalists and the public would permanently lose freedom of information as a tool for investigating the executive branch of government.

The IPC's cybersecurity warning carries a systemic implication beyond this specific scandal: if officials believe their personal devices are exempt from accountability, they will increasingly use personal devices for government business — creating precisely the security risk the government claims to be solving. The pattern here mirrors Bill 5, where retroactive changes were engineered to shield past decision-making from scrutiny and oversight mechanisms were removed before they could be applied. Public polling commissioned after the amendments were tabled found 60% of Ontarians opposed the changes, with only 24% in support — a clear signal that the government is acting against expressed public interest on a matter of fundamental democratic accountability.

Linked bills

Sources

  1. Ford government moves to make all premier, minister records secret — Global News
  2. Ford government proposes FOI law change that would keep premier's records secret — CBC News
  3. FOI changes would make Ontario the country's most secretive government — Globe and Mail
  4. Ontario FOI changes will make it "less transparent than even the federal government" — Global News
  5. Ontario's privacy watchdog is fact-checking Ford — National Observer
  6. Ford targets Ontario law that exposed his government's worst scandals — National Observer
  7. Ford accuses FOI watchdog of "politicizing" transparency — Global News
  8. IPC Statement on Proposed FIPPA Changes — Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario
  9. Bill 97 — Plan to Protect Ontario Act (Budget Measures), 2026: Legislative Status — Ontario Legislative Assembly
  10. Ontario to bypass public hearings on FOI overhaul — Global News
  11. Ford government to bypass public hearings on freedom of information clampdown — CP24
  12. Ford's jet purchase would be hidden under FOI changes — Global News
  13. Doug Ford is stifling the public's right to access government records — The Pointer
  14. Ontario's Bill 97 Threatens Government Accountability and Privacy — Canadian Civil Liberties Association
  15. NDP, Liberals speaking out after Ford government moves to host late-night session amid changes to FOI legislation — CP24
  16. Ontario passes freedom of information changes — Global News
  17. Why is Bill 97 Moving So Fast? — NCRNow
  18. Ontario government freezes freedom of information requests — Global News
  19. Ontario FOI freeze lifted; Ford dismisses critics as 'media party' — Global News
  20. Doug Ford's daily calendar kept secret after changes to Ontario's FOI law — CBC News
  21. Ontario's FOI changes are now law. Experts say they could hurt public trust — CBC News
  22. Ontario Modernizes Its Freedom of Information and Privacy Regime — Hicks Morley
  23. Bill 97 Introduces Major Changes to Privacy Legislation — Filion Wakely Thorup Angeletti
  24. Two legal battles over Greenbelt records 'likely' quashed by PCs' FOI restrictions — The Trillium
  25. Ford government's FOI changes block release of 219 Greenbelt 'investment-opportunity meeting' records — The Trillium
  26. Doug Ford's bike lane battle sparked behind-the-scenes commotion, records reveal — Toronto Star
  27. Project Redacted: Ontario politicians refuse to release records about their contacts with a Vaughan church leader — Investigative Journalism Bureau
  28. Legislative Assembly of Ontario: Bill 143, Plan to Protect Ontario Act (Budget Measures), 2026 (No. 2)
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here