ServiceOntario Outsourcing: A Sole-Sourced Staples Deal, and French-Language Services the Ministry Failed to Oversee
TL;DR
The Ford government sole-sourced a deal moving nine ServiceOntario centres into Staples stores; the FAO found it will cost $11.7M, $0.8M more than keeping the original operators on their old terms, though $1.2M less than keeping them with expanded service they say they were never offered. Separately, in October 2026 the French Language Services Commissioner found 12 ServiceOntario locations legally required to serve in French had no bilingual staff.
Key: People Related scandals
The web
2 peopleWhy it matters
The province moved nine ServiceOntario counters into Staples stores without a competition. CityNews reported the three-year deal was sole-sourced; the centres were relocated as the original private operators' agreements expired. Minister Todd McCarthy said the move was partly about saving taxpayers money, initially projected at $900,000 over three years. The Financial Accountability Office found the province had underestimated the cost: the agreement will cost $11.7 million to January 31, 2027, made up of $1.7 million in one-time set-up costs and $10.0 million in labour and overhead, against the province's own estimate of $10.2 million.
Whether the deal saves money depends on what it is compared with, and the FAO reported both answers. Against keeping the original operators on their previous terms, which the FAO notes is the same scenario the province used in its own January 2024 comparison, the Staples deal costs $0.8 million more. The province had claimed that comparison showed $0.9 million in savings. Against keeping the original operators with expanded hours and services, the FAO found the Staples deal would save $1.2 million. Operators told 680 NewsRadio they were never asked to provide that expanded service, according to CityNews. McCarthy's office stood by its savings claim, citing "more than $1.2 million in cost-savings and 50 per cent more hours of service" and saying "it is clear that this new approach to deliver more convenience and access is working."
The outsourcing question reaches far beyond nine counters. The FAO reported that in 2023-24, 195 of 276 in-person ServiceOntario centres (70.7 per cent) were privately operated. In October 2026 the French Language Services Commissioner found that the ministry responsible for ServiceOntario "failed for years to comply with regulatory reporting requirements related to services delivered by third-party operators," and that frontline staff at contracted locations were generally less aware of their French-language obligations than staff at provincially run ones. Commissioner Carl Bouchard told CBC News: "The Ministry provides little or no support to third-party operators to help them meet their linguistic obligations."
The commissioner's findings apply to ServiceOntario as a whole, not specifically to the Staples locations. His investigation, In search of services in French, found 12 locations required by law to serve the public in French had no bilingual employees at all, that locations routinely relied on translation tools or borrowed staff instead of bilingual service, and that audits sometimes gave passing scores to locations that were not meeting their obligations under the French Language Services Act. "These rights are not suggestions, nor are they mere administrative requirements," Bouchard said.
Rippling effects
The commissioner's investigation began in April 2025 after what he called a "trend" of complaints. CBC News reported the ministry had one of the highest numbers of complaints each year, and nearly all of them involved ServiceOntario. The people affected described being forced to finish transactions in English or with hand gestures, being sent away to come back another day, and having to translate private information aloud at the counter. In one case a man had to read out a letter from his employer about his status as a temporary resident. In another, a woman who asked for service in French was told by other customers that she was harassing staff.
The Ministry of Public and Business Service Delivery and Procurement and the Ministry of Francophone Affairs accepted 18 of the 25 recommendations and committed only to "reviewing" the rest, according to the Ombudsman's release. The ministry committed to meeting its reporting obligations, improving audits and setting minimum bilingual staffing requirements for contracted operators. A ministry spokesperson told CBC the government "will continue holding service providers to the highest standards."
The Staples agreement runs until January 31, 2027. The FAO's analysis shows the government's savings claim holds only against a scenario in which the original operators provide expanded service, which the operators say they were never asked to do. Staples Canada also appears on this site as the single vendor for the province's classroom-supply cards: see the Staples classroom-supply portal.
Sources
- ServiceOntario Relocations: Financial Analysis of the Agreement with Staples Canada — Financial Accountability Office of Ontario
- FAO releases report on cost of ServiceOntario relocations (Jan 15, 2025) — Financial Accountability Office of Ontario
- Ford government's ServiceOntario move to Staples will cost $11.7M, exceeding initial estimate: FAO — CityNews Toronto
- French Language Services Commissioner calls for significant improvements at ServiceOntario — Ombudsman Ontario
- In search of services in French: Investigation into the in-person delivery of French language services by ServiceOntario — Ombudsman Ontario
- ServiceOntario not meeting French-language service needs, ombudsman report says — CBC News

