Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

Ford's Blue Licence Plates: Unreadable at Night, Left on the Road, Records Fought Over in Court

TL;DR

Ontario's new blue licence plates rolled out on February 1, 2020, and within weeks police showed they were nearly unreadable at night, so the province stopped issuing them. Its plan to get them off the road turned out to be waiting for them to wear out, and in 2026 the government went to court to keep its records about the plates secret.

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

Why it matters

A licence plate has one job: to be read. The province's new blue "A Place to Grow" plates, announced in the 2019 budget and introduced on February 1, 2020, could not reliably do it. According to CHCH, a Kingston police officer, Sgt. Steve Koopman, posted a photo taken off duty "in a relatively well lit parking lot with my headlights on," asking: "Did anyone consult with police before designing and manufacturing the new Ontario licence plates? They're virtuallly unreadable at night." The Canadian Press reported the government and consumer services minister at the time initially insisted the plates were fine.

Within days the government changed course. PC House Leader Paul Calandra said the plates would likely be recalled once the problem was fixed by the manufacturer, 3M Canada. The government then announced it would stop distributing the plates at the end of day March 4, 2020. "We are pleased to have reached a resolution to this matter at no cost to Ontario taxpayers," said Lisa Thompson, Minister of Government and Consumer Services, adding that 3M Canada was providing material for an enhanced plate. CHCH reported that roughly 71,000 blue plates had been distributed in February; The Canadian Press later put the number initially issued at about 193,000.

Drivers who got the plates were told they would be contacted by mail with instructions on how to replace them. Instead, in February 2024, The Canadian Press revealed that the government's plan was to "naturally phase out" the plates through attrition, an approach a senior official said had been in place since November 2022. It was not made public until the province confirmed it to CP, after more than a year of fighting the release of records through a freedom-of-information request. The province had considered other options, including exchanging plates by mail, but they carried costs of $2.5 million to $3 million, and the government had committed to fixing the plates at no additional cost. Drivers who want to can exchange a blue plate for free at ServiceOntario, but as of that month 124,000 blue plates were still on the road.

The Ontario Association of Chiefs of Police had wanted the plates off the roads "as soon as possible," but the government did not ask the chiefs for input on the phase-out plan. "We've said to the government all along in terms of the blue plates that there are always concerns about the safety aspects of it," spokesperson Joe Couto told CP.

Rippling effects

What began as a design failure became a transparency fight. In November 2022, The Canadian Press asked for the government's plans to replace the blue plates. The government found 15 records and refused to release any of them, arguing they were civil servants' advice and would prematurely disclose a "pending policy decision." In August 2023 it told the Information and Privacy Commissioner the decision would be made public "in the future." A Canadian Press roundup of Ford government reversals noted that as of 2023 there were still 170,000 blue plates in circulation and no announced plan to remove them.

The IPC sided with the public. According to The Canadian Press, the commissioner found that while the exemptions applied, there was "a compelling public interest in disclosure of the records," which give "detailed information on the Ontario government's plans to replace the blue license plates, the different approaches that were considered, and the costs and benefits of each approach." The government asked for a reconsideration and lost again. Instead of releasing the records, it applied to court for a judicial review, arguing the IPC's public-interest finding "was made based on no or insufficient evidence."

Opposition leaders tied the case to the government's wider retreat from openness. "Secrecy is the status quo for the Ford government," said Green Leader Mike Schreiner. "If he's working this hard to cover up his licence plate slip-up, imagine what else he's hiding from us." Liberal ethics critic Stephanie Smyth noted the government had "lost at the IPC" and "lost again on reconsideration," and NDP Leader Marit Stiles called it "yet another frivolous court battle." CP noted the court fight comes after the government lost its bid to keep the premier's cellphone records secret and then passed a new law shielding the records of the premier, ministers and their staff. That law is covered in FIPPA Overhaul, and the broader pattern in The FOI Transparency Scandal.

Sources

  1. Ontario to stop issuing problematic blue licence plates in March — CHCH News
  2. Ontario's plan to get rid of blue licence plates is to sit back and wait — CityNews / The Canadian Press
  3. A list of policies and cuts the Doug Ford government has reversed — The Canadian Press (via Cornwall Seaway News)
  4. Ford government goes to court to fight FOI disclosure of blue licence plate documents — CityNews / The Canadian Press
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here