Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

The 2019 Autism Program Overhaul: Capped Funding, a "Four Long Years" Warning, and a Reversal

TL;DR

In February 2019 the Ford government replaced needs-based autism therapy funding with caps tied to a child's age and family income, and a behaviour analysts' association said Minister Lisa MacLeod warned of "four long years" if it did not publicly back the plan. After months of protests the government reversed course in July 2019, after an internal review by a PC MPP said its 23,000-child waitlist figure was "unverified and is likely inaccurate."

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

The web

4 people

Why it matters

The February 2019 program tied autism therapy funding to a child's age and family income rather than to what the child needed. Families would receive up to $20,000 a year until age six and up to $5,000 a year from six to 18, to a maximum of $140,000, while advocates said intensive therapy can cost up to $80,000 a year, CBC News reported. MacLeod reportedly told the Waterloo Region Record that Autism Ontario supported the plan; Autism Ontario said it "neither proposed nor endorsed" the changes.

The ministry also leaned on a professional body to sell the plan. ONTABA told its members that Lisa MacLeod and her staff asked for a quote of support a few days before the announcement, without sharing full details, and indicated that refusing would mean "four long years" for the organization. Her office never denied the assertion, instead saying the association was "unwavering" in its desire to self-regulate. MacLeod apologized on Twitter "if my comments made anyone feel threatened or uncomfortable." Doug Ford said he would "never ever" ask her to resign and called her an "absolute all-star."

Ontario's ethics watchdog said the law could not reach the allegation. Liberal MPP Michael Coteau asked the Integrity Commissioner to investigate. In his May 23, 2019 report, Commissioner J. David Wake found insufficient grounds for an inquiry: favourable media coverage for a policy is a political interest, not a private one, so the conduct could not breach section 4 of the Members' Integrity Act, 1994 "even if the allegation was proven to be true." He also declined to treat it as a breach of parliamentary convention, citing a 1995 precedent in which the office declined to inquire into a minister allegedly threatening agencies that opposed funding cuts. In her submissions MacLeod denied that she or her staff requested a quote, and said "four long years" was an expression of disappointment.

The number used to justify the overhaul did not hold up inside the government's own caucus. Toronto-area PC MPP Roman Baber wrote an internal review, dated June 13 and addressed to Ford and chief of staff Dean French, who had asked for it in April, according to The Globe and Mail. It said the repeated claim that 23,000 children were waiting was "unverified and is likely inaccurate," and that "it is incorrect to say that 23,000 kids are languishing without treatment." The Globe reported that the review said the government purposely spread misinformation about the costs and the backlog to justify a funding model that would leave families "destitute." Ford called it a "pretty good report," but his office then reiterated the 23,000 figure to the Globe.

Rippling effects

The plan set off protests across Ontario. Families held rallies at the offices of PC MPPs and packed the public galleries at Queen's Park, where, the Globe reported, some sobbed quietly and others were ejected for shouting at MacLeod or the premier. Some parents told CBC News they were preparing to sell their homes to pay for therapy. ONTABA acknowledged MacLeod's apology but kept calling on the government to drop its "one-sized fits all" funding model.

The government retreated in stages. In late March it doubled the program's budget to $600 million, up from the $321 million set out in February. After MacLeod was moved to Tourism, Culture and Sport in a June cabinet shuffle, her successor Todd Smith announced on July 29 that the province would move to a needs-based program: "We didn't get the redesign right the first time. I'm here to tell you that we will now." Asked whether families were owed an apology, he said, "We are certainly sorry for the anxiety this caused."

The reversal did not undo the damage quickly. The Globe reported that the new program would not be fully rolled out until April 2020, with an advisory panel still to design it, and children still in therapy under the old program were given another extension of up to six months. "We have just lost a year and families have gone through an incredible amount of pain and anxiety and suffering," Ontario Autism Coalition president Laura Kirby-McIntosh told the Globe. Coteau called the move a "retreat and reset," adding that "the harms already done cannot simply be undone."

Advocates also noted that the PCs had once been on their side. Kirby-McIntosh told CBC that the community had fought the previous Liberal government's age-five cutoff three years earlier, "and the Conservatives were right there with us." Then, she said, "they brought in a program that changed your funding amount when you have a birthday."

Sources

  1. Autism group says Ontario minister warned of 4 'long' years if they didn't publicly back changes — CBC News (The Canadian Press)
  2. Lisa MacLeod apologizes for pressuring group to support autism program — Global News
  3. Group acknowledges MacLeod's apology after they say she pressured them to support autism program — Global News
  4. Report re: The Honourable Lisa MacLeod, Minister of Children, Community and Social Services (May 23, 2019) — Office of the Integrity Commissioner of Ontario
  5. Ford says government needs to determine real number of autism waitlist after internal review found PCs inflated size — The Globe and Mail
  6. Ontario changes course on unpopular autism funding model, minister announces — CBC News
  7. Ontario government to reverse direction on autism program and provide families with needs-based support — The Globe and Mail
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here