Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

Ford Government's Home-Care Supply Overhaul Collapsed, Leaving Palliative Patients Without Pain Medication

TL;DR

In September 2024, Ontario Health atHome, the home-care agency the Ford government created that June, cut 65 medical-supply contracts to 15, and the supply chain broke down within weeks. An internal memo obtained by The Trillium says three palliative patients died without pain medication and one without nutrition because supplies were delayed; the Patient Ombudsman found the agency had "no contingency plans in place."

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

The web

5 people

Why it matters

The supply overhaul was a government design, not a local accident. The Patient Ombudsman's report says the Ministry of Health directed Ontario Health in 2020 to modernize home-care supply purchasing and that the government approved the centralized approach in July 2021. The Trillium reports that a mandate letter from Health Minister Sylvia Jones told the new agency to "capture better value for health care dollars" by centralizing purchases, and that an internal OHaH memo projected savings of about $156 million over five years.

The people hurt were among the most vulnerable in the health system. More than half of the patients the ombudsman's office interviewed were receiving palliative care. An internal OHaH memo to the Ministry of Health, obtained by The Trillium, says: "In three known cases, palliative patients died without pain medications and one patient died without nutrition because supplies were delayed." The ombudsman's report describes a patient with three forms of Stage 4 cancer whose symptom-relief kit arrived less than 10 minutes before they died; according to The Canadian Press, the report quotes the doctor as saying the patient "died choking and in pain."

Warnings came before the launch. The ombudsman found that concerns about the accuracy of the forecast data "had been communicated to Ontario Health and Ontario Health atHome well before the go-live date." Witnesses estimated a project of this size needed about 18 months; the time allotted was less than eight months, which the ombudsman said was "largely outside of Ontario Health atHome's control given the funding parameters of the Ontario government." According to a memo from then-CEO Cynthia Martineau quoted by The Trillium, the previous suppliers had a 30-day termination clause and had already prepared to stand down, so "making a go/no-go implementation decision immediately prior to implementation was not feasible."

The ombudsman found OHaH "had no contingency plans in place" and "observed an attitude of complacency," because smaller contract changes had gone smoothly in the past. The new supply list carried far fewer products, and the ombudsman found no one assessed what relying on fewer supplies and fewer manufacturers would do to the supply chain. Training for health-care providers started only two weeks before go-live, and patients and caregivers received no formal notice at all.

Rippling effects

Nurses and patients improvised. Health-worker notes obtained by The Trillium describe wreath hangers sent to homes in Toronto as substitutes for IV poles, a Hamilton/Niagara nursing manager who "bartered supplies," patients reusing nephrostomy bags, and clients receiving empty boxes with backorder notices. Clinics sent patients to emergency rooms for IV antibiotics, and some refused because they could not afford the $45 ambulance fee. The ombudsman's report describes a patient with a serious arm infection, at risk of amputation, who had to go to hospital after home deliveries of IV antibiotics were missed.

Children were affected too. The Trillium reports that items needed by paediatric patients were left off the consolidated supply list, and OHaH had to ask SickKids to supply them from its own stock. The list was not updated until December 17, 2024, nearly three months after the disruption began.

Patients and families paid out of pocket. As of February 11, 2025, OHaH had paid 932 reimbursement claims totalling $590,125, according to the ombudsman. CEO Cynthia Martineau was fired in January 2025. When the report came out, the agency's interim CEO and board chair apologized, writing, as reported by The Canadian Press, that "we did not meet our commitment to high quality patient care." OHaH says it has implemented all four of the ombudsman's recommendations.

Accountability has not settled anywhere. Minister Jones said the agency "failed in its basic responsibility to patients, caregivers and families." OHaH called the "issue with the vendor" that led to the disruption "unacceptable." Neither answered The Trillium's detailed questions about the documents. Jane Meadus, a lawyer with the Advocacy Centre for the Elderly, told The Trillium she did not think OHaH came up with the idea: "It was the government." The disruption is part of a wider pattern of strain in Ontario's care system documented in Ontario's health-care job cuts and the long-term care 'homes in distress' bailouts.

Sources

  1. 'Pain crisis': Inside the supply shortage that devastated Ontario's home care system — The Trillium
  2. Lack of planning, oversight led to Ontario home care supply shortages: ombudsman — Global News / The Canadian Press
  3. Investigation Report Findings: Home Care Medical Supplies Disruption (September 2025) — Patient Ombudsman
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here