Finance Minister Rod Phillips Vacationed in St. Barts During the Pandemic, and Ford Knew
TL;DR
Finance Minister Rod Phillips flew to St. Barts on December 13, 2020 while his government urged Ontarians to avoid non-essential travel, and his social media kept posting as if he were home. Doug Ford learned of the trip shortly after it began but did not order him back; Phillips resigned from cabinet on December 31, two days after the trip became public.
Key: People Related scandals
The web
2 peopleWhy it matters
The trip happened while the government Phillips sat in was telling the public to stay put. On December 15, two days after he left, Ontario reported a then-record 2,275 new COVID-19 cases and Health Minister Christine Elliott asked people to "stay in your own homes as much as possible," according to CBC's timeline of the trip. Rod Phillips, the province's finance minister, was in St. Barts the whole time and stayed there after the province-wide lockdown began on Boxing Day.
For more than two weeks the public was not told. Posts on Phillips's social media accounts during the trip could, as CBC put it, "arguably give the impression he was home for the holidays": photos from local announcements his staff later said were taken before he left, a Zoom appearance in front of a virtual Queen's Park backdrop, and a Christmas Eve video by a fireplace. Phillips later said politicians routinely pre-record such content, but that "I understand in the circumstances why it seemed insincere."
The premier knew. On the night the story broke, Doug Ford's office said he "was not aware of the minister's trip, nor did his office approve it." The next day Ford admitted he had called Phillips "shortly after he arrived" and learned he was away, and said: "I should have said get your backside back into Ontario and I didn't do that." NDP Leader Andrea Horwath said that "not only did Ford not fire him then, he helped him keep the trip a secret," according to CBC's report on the resignation.
It was not the first trip. Phillips's office confirmed to CBC that he had also taken a personal trip to Switzerland in August 2020, meaning he left the country at least twice during the pandemic. Ford, asked about the St. Barts trip, said: "There can't be rules for elected people and non-elected people."
Rippling effects
Phillips resigned as finance minister on December 31, 2020, around 48 hours after the trip became public. Ford said the resignation showed "our government takes seriously our obligation to hold ourselves to a higher standard," and named Treasury Board President Peter Bethlenfalvy finance minister, with the job of delivering the 2021 budget (Canadian Press via the Sault Star).
Phillips kept his seat. He told reporters at Pearson airport he would have liked to keep his cabinet job, and in his resignation statement said he would focus on "continuing to serve the people of Ajax as their Member of Provincial Parliament." He was to quarantine in Ajax for 14 days after landing.
The opposition said the resignation came only because the trip was exposed. Horwath said: "Phillips's resignation from cabinet today is not because of Phillips's vacation, it's because they got caught." Liberal Leader Steven Del Duca said Ford "admittedly knew about Phillips's vacation and did nothing to stop it," and asked why Phillips faced no consequences for the August trip.
For other controversies over Ford government travel and spending, see Ford's Texas trade trip expenses and the MPP hotel expense scandal.

