Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

Ford's Mandatory Anti-Carbon-Tax Gas Pump Stickers Struck Down as Unconstitutional

TL;DR

A 2019 Ford government law forced Ontario's roughly 3,200 gas stations to post provincial stickers attacking the federal carbon tax, under threat of daily fines. In September 2020 the Superior Court struck it down as compelled partisan speech, and the province did not appeal.

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

Why it matters

A government is free to campaign against another government's policy. What it cannot do, the court found, is pass a law forcing private businesses to carry that campaign for it. The Federal Carbon Tax Transparency Act, 2019 required the operator of every retail gas outlet to obtain the prescribed notice from the Minister and fix it to each pump. As CBC News reported, Justice Edward Morgan wrote that a government or party "can, in the words of Ontario's Minister of Energy, 'stick it to' another tier of government or political party as a matter of free speech," but "a government cannot legislate a requirement that private retailers post a sticker designed to accomplish that task. The mandatory fuel pump sticker is an attempt to do just that."

The ministers' own words were used against the law. Law Times reports that the judge pointed to Doug Ford telling the press that people "have to know how the federal government is gouging them on the worst single tax you could ever put on the backs of people," to Vic Fedeli saying "We will be putting stickers on gas pumps that show just how much Justin Trudeau is taking out of your pocket," and to Greg Rickford telling the legislature the government would let Ontarians know "where it hurts the most, when they're fuelling up their automobiles." Justice Morgan found the timing, "with a federal election only months away," and the sticker's wording reflected the law's partisan thrust.

The law carried real penalties. Under section 4 of the Act, an individual operator who failed to post the sticker faced a fine of up to $500 for every day of a first offence and up to $1,000 a day for a repeat offence, while a corporation faced up to $5,000 a day, rising to $10,000 a day for a repeat offence. The Act also let ministry inspectors enter gas stations to check compliance, and exposed directors and officers of operating companies to the same fines if they failed to take reasonable care to ensure the stickers were posted. In August 2019, Ford said his government would fine stations that did not display the stickers, though at less than $500 rather than the $10,000 maximum.

The sticker law delivered the government's message through private businesses rather than through its own channels. The government's paid advertising, and how partisan it has been, is covered in Ontario's Secret Advertising Machine.

Rippling effects

The ruling freed gas stations to keep the stickers or take them down as they saw fit, CBC reported. The NDP's energy critic Peter Tabuns called on Ford not to "waste another dollar of public money" appealing. On October 1, 2020 the government announced it would not, with Rickford saying in a statement reported by Law Times that "Ontarians deserve to know the true cost of the federal carbon tax" but that the government's "sole focus" was the COVID-19 response. The Superior Court decision therefore stands.

The case, CCLA v. Attorney General of Ontario, 2020 ONSC 4838, is one of the few Canadian rulings on compelled speech. PEN Canada intervened, and its co-counsel Evan Rankin told Law Times it is "a good reminder – to the government especially" that "statements made in the legislature by ministers are important and they can come back to haunt the government."

In April 2019 the government told The Canadian Press it would spend about $5,000 to print 25,000 stickers, an estimate that did not cover distributing them to 3,200 gas stations. Opposition politicians accused the government of wasting tax dollars and abusing legal tools to bolster its campaign against carbon pricing.

Sources

  1. Ontario court strikes down Doug Ford's mandatory anti-carbon tax gas pump stickers — CBC News
  2. Comments by ministers in legislature and media used against government in carbon tax sticker ruling — Law Times
  3. Federal Carbon Tax Transparency Act, 2019, S.O. 2019, c. 7, Sched. 23 — Ontario e-Laws
  4. Doug Ford vows to fine gas stations that don't display anti-carbon tax stickers — CBC News / The Canadian Press
  5. Anti-carbon tax stickers will cost Ontario government at least $5K — CBC News / The Canadian Press
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here