Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

The Landlord and Tenant Board Collapse: Ombudsman Finds the Tribunal "Fundamentally Failing"

TL;DR

After the 2018 election, the number of adjudicators appointed to Ontario's Landlord and Tenant Board fell rapidly, and by early 2020 the board had a backlog of more than 20,000 applications. In May 2023 the Ombudsman found it "fundamentally failing," with more than 38,000 cases waiting and some tenant applications taking up to two years just to be scheduled.

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

Why it matters

The Landlord and Tenant Board is where Ontario's renters and landlords go to settle disputes over evictions, unpaid rent, repairs and harassment. It only works if there are enough adjudicators to hear cases, and only cabinet can appoint them. In December 2019, CBC reported that the Ford government was facing blame for failing to fill some 20 vacant adjudicator posts. The board had 49 adjudicators in April 2018; by late 2019 it had 39, and only 28 were actively hearing cases. A Tribunals Ontario spokesperson confirmed "a lower than normal number of adjudicators." The share of hearings scheduled within the board's own 25-business-day standard fell from 54 per cent in 2017-18 to 35 per cent in 2018-19, and to 24 per cent in the April-to-June 2019 quarter.

Ombudsman Paul Dubé's investigation found that by fall 2019 the board "had spiraled into a moribund state." Ministry, board and Tribunals Ontario officials initially attributed the delays "to the recent election and a resulting reduction in appointments of adjudicators." By the time COVID-19 arrived in March 2020, the backlog was already more than 20,000 applications; by the 2023 report it was more than 38,000. "As an administrative tribunal, the Board is fundamentally failing in its role of providing swift justice," Dubé wrote. "In doing so, it is denying justice to a significant segment of Ontarians."

The human cost was spelled out in the Ombudsman's release, which drew on more than 4,000 complaints: "There were tenants stuck waiting while they endured harassment, unsafe living conditions, and improper attempts to force them from their homes. And there were small landlords... facing financial ruin and serious health harms." Hearings that once took days to schedule now took seven to eight months, and some tenant applications took up to two years. In January 2023, the queue still held tenant applications dating back to 2017.

The Ombudsman did not put all of the blame on the government. CBC reported that Dubé described a "perfect storm" including the 2018 election, inefficient practices and the pandemic, and told reporters: "I don't blame a new government for having to find its way. I blame a system that's so precarious." But three of his 61 recommendations were aimed at the province, calling for legislative changes to remove impediments to appointing members, including limits on how turnovers in government can reduce the board's capacity to issue decisions.

Rippling effects

The board's leadership and structure changed under the Ford government. Writing in Law360 Canada in February 2025, Kathy Laird, a member of Tribunal Watch Ontario and former director of the Advocacy Centre for Tenants Ontario, argued that after the government moved the LTB into the new Tribunals Ontario in January 2019 it replaced experienced leadership, "often with Tory insiders." Citing Tribunals Ontario data, she wrote that the average tenant wait for a hearing went from 40 days in 2018 to 277 days in 2024, that the government closed 44 regional hearing centres, and that of more than 74,000 LTB hearings in 2023/24, only 25 were held in person. These are her figures and her argument, published as opinion.

Tenant advocates warned early about where the delays could lead. In 2019, Kenn Hale of the Advocacy Centre for Tenants Ontario told CBC that a broken process "creates pressure to say, 'Why don't we just cut back on people's rights a bit? Why don't we make it a little easier for landlords to push their applications through?'" The government's later changes to eviction rules at the same tribunal are covered in Bill 60: "Fighting Delays" Fast-Tracks Evictions.

The government's response to the 2023 report was to defend its record. A spokesperson for the Attorney General pointed to $6.5 million to hire more adjudicators and $28.5 million for a new case management system, and said the report "examined the Landlord Tenant Board (LTB) at a previous moment in time." NDP MPP Jessica Bell said: "The Conservatives have had five years to fix the Landlord and Tenant Board, and this report shows they've made the problem worse." The Ombudsman urged the province to move quickly on its pledge of 40 more adjudicators, warning that recruitment and training timelines could otherwise delay any improvement.

Sources

  1. Administrative Justice Delayed, Fairness Denied — Ombudsman Ontario investigation report (May 2023)
  2. Ombudsman calls for legislative change, overhaul of "moribund" Landlord and Tenant Board — Ombudsman Ontario (May 4, 2023)
  3. Ontario's Landlord and Tenant Board 'fundamentally failing,' ombudsman finds — CBC News
  4. Growing delays at Ontario rental tribunal have tenants fearing what Ford government will do next — CBC News
  5. Under the Ford government: Justice delayed and denied at Tribunals Ontario (Kathy Laird, opinion) — Law360 Canada
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here