Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

Ontario Paid $210M in COVID Business Grants to Ineligible Recipients, Then Wrote It Off

$210M+Cost to Ontario

3 sources ↓

TL;DR

The Auditor General found Ontario paid more than $210 million in Small Business Support Grants to about 14,500 ineligible recipients and chose not to try to recover any of it, while nearly half of recipients got about $714 million more than they lost and some hard-hit businesses got nothing. Premier Doug Ford's answer: "I think more people benefited than got hurt."

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

Why it matters

The Auditor General's 2021 audit found that Ontario's emergency business supports had no working filter. The Ontario Small Business Support Grant offered two payments of $10,000 to $20,000 each to businesses with fewer than 100 employees that were ordered closed and lost more than 20 per cent of their revenue. More than $210 million went to recipients who did not qualify, and the province "has chosen not to attempt to recover any of this money." CBC reported that money went to 14,500 ineligible recipients, with another $6 million still being investigated.

The money was also badly aimed. Because the minimum grant was $10,000, 46 per cent of businesses that received one were paid about $714 million more than they lost. Hard-hit businesses in the accommodation and other services sectors were left out, and businesses that lost revenue but were not ordered to close did not qualify at all. The province did not even know how much money had reached businesses, because it was not tracking all payouts. "Given the amount of money, the absence of better controls or assessment processes is troubling," Bonnie Lysyk said.

The problems ran through the other programs too. The province paid $16 million in property tax and energy rebates to more than 3,000 ineligible recipients. Under the Ontario Together Fund, a $1.8 million contract went to a business that went bankrupt, and 15 of 54 projects were delayed because monitoring was inconsistent. According to the Canadian Press summary of the report, the Economic Development Ministry did not identify two perceived conflicts of interest, including one where the CEO of a company that received $2.5 million sat on the COVID-19 Vaccine Task Force. "It's not acceptable. There should have been a declaration of a conflict of interest," Lysyk told reporters.

Above all of it sat $51 billion in economic supports announced for 2020 to 2024, with neither short- nor long-term objectives set for the money. "Even in a crisis, systems should be in place to make sure that only eligible businesses receive taxpayer dollars, and program funds reach those who need it most," Lysyk said.

Rippling effects

The government's response was to shrug. Asked about the findings, Premier Doug Ford said the province moved quickly: "When we're rushing the money out the door to support the small businesses that were in desperate need of it, unfortunately, you're going to see some fraud." He added, according to CBC, "I think more people benefited than got hurt." The written-off $210 million was not pursued.

The cost was not only the money that went to the wrong places. The Auditor General found the province did not clearly explain the basis for public health restrictions or warn businesses before imposing or lifting them. More than two-thirds of businesses surveyed said they did not have enough time to adapt, and many restaurant owners lost thousands of dollars throwing out food. The businesses the grant left out absorbed those losses without help.

The same report found broader failures in how the province handled public money and emergencies: more than 80 per cent of Ontario's emergency PPE stockpile had expired by 2017, and the Ministry of Health had begun destroying expired PPE without replacing it. Questions about how the Ford government hands out money to businesses did not end with the pandemic: see the Skills Development Fund and the Protect Ontario Fund.

Sources

  1. The Government Paid Millions of Dollars in COVID-19 Support to Ineligible Businesses: Auditor General — Office of the Auditor General of Ontario (news release, Dec 1, 2021)
  2. Ontario gave $210M in COVID-19 support to ineligible businesses, auditor general's report finds — CBC News / The Canadian Press
  3. Key findings from Ontario auditor general's annual report — Global News / The Canadian Press
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here