Pandemic Parent Payments: No Custody Checks
TL;DR
Ontario's Ministry of Education paid out more than $2 billion through five direct payment programs for parents between 2020 and 2023, paying whoever applied first without checking custody. The Acting Ombudsman found that hundreds of custodial parents and guardians were denied money meant for their children, and that the ministry never tracked how much went to the wrong people.
Key: People Related scandals
The web
3 peopleWhy it matters
The five programs were meant to help families whose children's schooling was disrupted, first by the 2020 education labour dispute and then by pandemic school closures: Support for Parents, Support for Families, Support for Learners, the Ontario COVID-19 Child Benefit and Catch Up Payments. Together they paid out more than $2 billion. The Ombudsman's report says that "anyone who had the most basic information about a child or youth could apply, and if their application was first in the Ministry's system, they would receive payments." The applications asked for details such as the child's name, date of birth and school board. No form asked for proof of custody, and staff said they were "expressly directed not to request or accept documents from applicants offering such proof." One director told investigators the ministry "had no way of knowing whether or not the person [who] received the payment [was] a parent or an aunt or … the guy on the street."
The Ombudsman received more than 200 complaints. Some came from parents with sole custody, and some from parents with a restraining order against the other parent. Others found that relatives or strangers had claimed the money. A single mother with sole custody of five children was refused because the father of two of them, who had had no contact with them for years, had applied first. She sent court documents, and staff told her the program was "first come, first served." A grandmother raising her grandson was refused because his mother, who had neither custody nor contact, had already been paid. In one case an uncle collected payments for his nieces without their parents knowing; the matter was referred to police, and the parents were still left out.
The ministry knew early and did not change course. A partner ministry flagged "eligibility risks" while the first program was being designed. By May 2020, a month into the second program, the ministry had received almost 300 custody-related complaints and inquiries. Instead of verifying eligibility, it added a line saying the applicant "should" have custody, removed it for the third program and restored it for the fourth. Only with the fifth program, in October 2022, did applicants have to attest that they had custody. For the second and fourth programs, earlier recipients were "rolled over" automatically, so people the ministry had already been told were ineligible were paid again. Acting Ombudsman Barbara Finlay found the programs were "rushed and plagued by problems that were replicated at each iteration instead of being fixed."
Parents who complained hit a wall. According to the report, they received "a boilerplate response, stating that the Ministry could not get involved in custody matters," and were told to recover the money themselves, "even as the Ministry refused to disclose who the recipient was." The response stayed the same where a parent disclosed a history of abuse. By the fifth program, the small escalation team had faced upwards of 50,000 complaints and inquiries, and thousands of emails went unanswered. "Whoever screamed loudest got served first," one staff member said. An appeal process, open only to Catch Up Payments applicants, ran from January 29 to February 29, 2024, ten months after that program closed. It was "intentionally not widely publicized, to keep appeal volumes low," and drew 25 appeals against that program's 1.7 million applications.
The money cannot be traced. "Hundreds of families were denied benefits to which they were entitled," Finlay wrote. "The Ministry does not know the exact amount because it failed to make any effort to track improperly distributed funds." With no recovery mechanism and no record of which payments should have been clawed back, the report says there is "no realistic way to recover this money or to compensate the families who lost out." The Ombudsman found the ministry's administration of the programs "unreasonable, unjust, and wrong" under the Ombudsman Act.
Rippling effects
The ministry accepted all 14 recommendations, which apply only to future programs: plan and staff programs properly, set clear eligibility rules and verify them before money goes out, audit verification, check rolled-over recipients, resource the complaints process, build a way to recover misdirected funds, and open a publicized appeal process at launch. According to the Ombudsman's release, the ministry said the programs were delivered "outside of its usual program delivery model during an unprecedented period that required rapid action." None of the recommendations returns money to families who missed out.
The government defended the programs. CBC reported that Emma Testani, press secretary to Education Minister Paul Calandra, said: "When students and families faced unprecedented disruptions to in-person learning, our government took immediate action by providing direct financial support to millions of Ontario families." When former Ombudsman Paul Dubé announced the investigation in December 2023, a spokeswoman for then-Education Minister Stephen Lecce said the province was working with the Ombudsman and that the programs had helped support 1.8 million students, CBC reported. Announcing Catch Up Payments in October 2022, Lecce said, "I have confidence that parents in the province will put this money to work for their kids" (CBC).
Opposition politicians said the findings fit a pattern. Ontario Liberal interim leader John Fraser told CBC the government "just pushes money out the door without thinking through the implications," and NDP education critic Chandra Pasma said: "You knew you were getting complaints. You know your approach isn't working then, why would you not try another one." Another pandemic program that paid people who were not eligible, and did not get the money back, is covered in COVID business grants paid to ineligible recipients.
On October 27, 2026, the Speaker informed the House that Catching Up on Fairness had been tabled during the adjournment, according to Hansard. Coverage at release came from CityNews and CTV News as well as CBC.
Sources
- Catching Up on Fairness — Ombudsman Ontario investigation report (June 2026)
- Ombudsman investigation finds Ministry of Education direct payment programs unfairly denied payments to some eligible families — Ombudsman Ontario (June 25, 2026)
- Ontario unfairly denied pandemic payouts to some parents, guardians: ombudsman's report — CBC News
- Ontario Ombudsman finds families unfairly denied COVID-era payments — CityNews Toronto
- Hundreds of Ontario parents were denied pandemic payments they were entitled to. Here is why — CTV News Toronto
- Ontario ombudsman launches investigation into province's payouts to parents — CBC News (Dec. 11, 2023)
- Ontario announces 'catch up payments' for parents as Lecce blames low math scores on pandemic — CBC News (Oct. 20, 2022)
- Hansard, October 27, 2026: Tabling of sessional papers — Legislative Assembly of Ontario


